10 from me, enjoyed it from start to end.
10 for the years of abuse suffered by Jesse coming out in a violent burst of aggression. Oh and a great glimpse of Rosita's cleavage.

 

8/10

[HR][/HR]8/10.

 

10, one of my favorite episodes definitely!!

 

Carol, I love you
carol is a Goddess
Burqua of death. LOL

 

10. Best episode of TWD in a looong time.

 

Carol/10

 

I'm rewatching right now, and I think I'll give this one a 9.

I enjoyed exploring Enid's backstory. I enjoyed some of the bigger major characters like Rick, Daryl and Michonne being absent and allowing some of the smaller characters to get some screentime. I loved Carol's stealthy defence tactics. She's 100% the most interesting character the series has.

I have some complaints about the handling of Morgan, but I won't go into it right now as I've already posted these thoughts in another thread. I'm sure most people can probably guess what my concern is, as it appears to be a common criticism.

 

10. Loved it. It was great how I was all settled in to a week of Enid back story and Alexandrian homemaking and then BAM! Smoking Kills!

It was one of the best, most horrific episodes ever. And yet still moved some characters along their paths. Just a crazy good episode from start to finish.

 

This one was a solid 9. I can't give it a 10 because no Rick, of course, but Carol was so incredibly badass. That shot of her looking up while painting the W on her forehead with blood will forever be emblazoned in my mind. Just awesome.

 

Heck, if I'm Jessie, I try to do a total swap: adopt Carl, and chuck Ron out into the street.

 

I had the temptation on the poll to rate it "At least it's better then Z Nation" just because it made me chuckle.

A very solid 9/10.
Extremely good episode, could have been a 10/10 contender but didn't quite reach the greatness of Days Gone By, No Sanctuary, Clear and The Grove, my 4 current 10/10's.

 

It was a 7/10 for me this episode.
A little bit too much wasted time, but great scenes with Carol (who die this season i believe QQ), Jessie and Morgan.
The rest of it was pretty "meh" in my opinion. Or atleast i`ve expected too much, idk.
That "i don`t kill anybody"-Thinking from Morgan is very unbelievable for me, after all the time out of THIS zombieworld, but yeah...

So it wasn`t a topepisode for me in the end, but we are still at the beginning of season 6, so i can live with it.

 

Fantastic episode!! 9.5!!!

 

I gave it an 8. -1 Because no Rick obviously. The action was unexpected and the stakes were an all time high. It was nice to see the different reactions of dealing with the situation. The normal Alexandrians who never got to see the terror the world is submerged in went all out panic and crying, with the survivors actually jumping to action without a blink of an eye.

I think this is all leading to Deanna formally giving Rick Alexandria's leadership because now she know how dangerous the world trully is.

And finally, I was very nervous of what Morgan said to the Wolves:

 

An absolute 10 & mainly due to carol & her badass attitude, especially when it comes to saving people from her "network". First at terminus, now alexandria. Not bad for a once meek & mild housewife.

 

Been wavering between 9 and 10 for a few days before I got to watch it again. Decided on a 10 in the end because once the action started I was gripped until it finished. Not many episodes like that. Loved Carol - from when she put down Mrs Neidermeyer principally because of her ridiculously petty concerns, I think - through The Grove-like view from the kitchen window seeing Mrs N hacked to death (! Remember Lizzie playing with the walker) to her awesome wolf get up and subsequent actions. I also liked Carl...seeming to struggle to become the clinical killer he once was and actually Morgan too. Struggles for him too - looked like he may be walking out at the end. Oh and Jessie came alive in this episode big style! Starting to care about some of the Alexandrians now.

 

Freakin Carol! She's just a killer. I think they have done such a good job with her. She seems exactly like what so many would become in a world like this. Excellent work. If only Daryl had been in town cleaning out the town too this would have been perfect (not a complaint just what I would like to see more often).
Morgan was annoying with his "I don't kill nobody" Im-kinda-like-Tyreese thing but I get what they are trying to do. The forced little visual of Carol and Morgan walking different paths was a bit thick.
Carl hesitating like that though...whack. Totally lame. It's like they've taken Carl back to season 2. Too bad. He could be a cool character.
We gave the episode a 10 - we're generous folk

 

My rating: 3