@Neuropyramidal would you pretty please add a 9.9 rating choice?

....The vomiting on Rosita stopped it from being a 10

 

but I had just eaten pizza....deduction worthy for sure

so how about it? a 9.9 option?

 

I must say, it may be just me but the second half of S8 has been way better than the first half. I give tonight's episode a 9. It wasn't filled with the most action but it was very, um "dramatic" I think. And it didn't have so many badly "get the hell out of here" scenario's that have plagued a couple of the last episodes. And the Simon Negan fight was pretty cool. Oh, and Laura and Eugene need to die. That is all.

 

It was alright. Hate to see Simon go and especially the way he did. Rosita still pisses me off. She's the reason Eugene is where he is. She conveniently forgot about that.

 

I gave it a 9.

The opening scene - Rick reading Carl’s note - was perfect.

The final scene - Michonne reading Carl’s note to Negan over the walkie-talky was perfect.

The Eugene/Gabriel scene near the end was great.

The rest of the episode was very well done. It set up great tension for next week’s season finale. I can’t wait to see all these developing sub-plots play out.

 

Wow. 10. Without a doubt.

Worth is a 10 and now I am hype that Wrath will push the envelope even further!

 

Dwights double double dealings and negans nice surprise for him. Worth was worth it for that alone.

 

After having slept off the shock of vomigeddon I am now okay wiht giving the episode a 10

I loved it. I will not even deduct points for Jesus absence, that is how much enjoyed the episode. The tension level was perfectly set. Negan was scary AF in a sinister kind of way - which is my preference.

Hell I even gave Daryl an "atta boy"!!

And well Dwight....Austin Amelio never disappoints

 

I give it a 9.
I honestly didn’t like the vomit scene. It was too projectile, and didn’t seem real.
Otherwise, loved it.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

I think this was my favorite episode of the season..

The 1st half of the season was ok, it could be better but i'm not one of these people that complain.

The 2nd half is really awesome!

This episode had it all, Great twists in the Sanctuary with Negan, Simon and Dwight. great acting from all of them and i liked the fight between Negan and Simon.

Walker Simon was so cool as well!

Nice to know what Cooorl's letters were about.

As much as i want to hate Eugene i just cant and i hope he makes something to save the survivors.

Last but not least, my love Rosita has evolved as one of my favorite characters of the show!

 

Will still have to give this episode a 6. Some of the things definitely were good but then there were things (as there are now with every TWD episode it seems) that were so so bad. The throwing up scene was laughably awful. I get what they were trying to do with Negan/Simon/Dwight in this episode but I definitely think they could have come up with a better way of telling that story than some junior high style fight scene where two people are fighting and everyone else is just standing in a circle around them.

And I still can't believe why no one has killed Negan yet. An idiot leader like him would never make it very long without being killed without plot armor attached to him. At least they have toned down his perverted behavior so he is actually watchable but I still don't buy into his character at all.

I'm just glad that there is only one more episode left of this atrociously awful written war.

 

I am giving it a 5. But ONLY because i fell asleep half way through!!!! GRRRR. The other half of the episode will be rated tomorrow........stay tuned.

 

I gave it a 9.5, really great and everything I had hoped for, totally tense all the way through. I knew old what's his name was gonna buy it. Hurrah!

 

I gave it a 10. That episode was really great to watch.

 

9.
9.
9. It was very good I'm excited for the finale can't wait to watch it live!!

 

9, best episode of Season 8B so far. Only thing I didn't like was how easily Eugene escaped a certified tracker in daryl, but all else was really great.