I must be a sadist

I sooo wanted Lily to shoot TG in the balls!!!

 

Complaints!

Ok first of all i am a big fan of the show. I've watched since the first episode of the first season and enjoyed it ever since. It's just there are a few things that could be easily fixed to make more sense. Number one, how does a TANK sneak up on you? If there are no cars then a caravan of vehicles including a tank would make a hugeeeee amount of noise! Also the walkers would hear the tank and follow it yet there were barely any walkers at the time of the attack. Another thing is that a guard should be in the tower at all times. Also if the walkers are attracted to things moving why are there no things like curtains covering the SEE THROUGH fences? And you would think that you would reinforce the fences knowing what happened at the farm with the herd and the MEGA HERD out there. Also the bus and other cars should be packed up at all times in case of emergencies like this. These are just things that popped in to my mind while watching the show and thinking about it the day after. Please let me know what you think. This is my first choice. If I'm wrong about something let me know but please don't just say I'm an ass or something. The walking dead is based in a universe where sound exists if I'm not mistaken and they should therefore be able to hear a TANK approaching.

 

I agree with this post mostly. If Rick had been talking to rational people there wouldn't have been any violence. I believe his speech would've swayed all but two of the people there. But with men like the Gov. and Mitch words are pointless. That situation was going to end the way it did no matter what Rick said or did.

 

A tank shakes a whole city block when driving by. Even if they were inside they would be able to hear something because there is no other sound but animals. If you hear gunshots you will know there are people, same as a car. But say they couldn't hear it then there still should have been someone in the guard tower to alert the rest of them if something happens. The bus was said to be packed up from the last run. what i got from that was there were not full suplies since they used some on the last run. And clearjng what follows them seems unlikely because of the time it would take, the danger of being killed and more would just come to the sound of the motors running. And what you said about the fences honestly does not make sense to me no offense. There are houses all over, you're saying they cant take apart stuff from a house to help? And covers would work great! If a walker does not try to walk through a wall why would they walk through a fence that looks like a wall and is not see through? The walkers wouldn't be able to see the prison people and therefore would not be interested. It has been months since the first governor encounter. They prison group had lots of time to prep for any type of situation and become stronger and more organized. These are just things that dont make sense to me and could easily be fixed.

 

Ok so how about the walkers that were in hershel's barn? The only time they went crazy trying to get out was when someone would come in the barn or come close to it. Ricks whole group had no idea they were in there because they were so dosile. Yet the walkers still can hear and smell the people. That goes to show that taking away the walkers vision does work. Reinforcing the fences would be a much better thing to do than have to keep clearing out the walkers from the outside of the fences. And about the morale, im pretty sure seeing the walkers would just remind me of death at my doorstep so i'd much rather have them out of sight, especially for the childrens sake. Living in a "box" as you say is the same as living inside of the prison. Also, woodburry was having gladiator fights and bbq's, that didnt seem to attract walkers as much as when walkers SEE a person.

 

Well what logic would you say i should use? The only logic i can use is from the same show, otherwise i can use logic from superman and rick can develop super strength and heat vision to get rid of all the walkers. About the turning doorknobs and stuffed animals, if it was in the show then it is possible to happen in the show. I dont know what else to say to that. And the CDC guy said that some people transform at different rates so i have no problem with that. And i dont know how you're saying my comparisson to seasons is invalid. The only thing we can go by is what the show shows us. If the show contradicts itself then there is a problem. I'm not saying that the walkers are ONLY agitated by sound, i'm saying that by sight being eliminated then they wouldn't be AS agitated. You can put up a curtain, like i said in my first post, that both eliminates sight and is easy to take down to clear the walkers. For sound i guess just try to be as quiet as possible and for smell, which isn't used too often in the show, just put the walker blood on the camp or on yourselves as they did in the first season to rescue myrle.

 

I am 'married' to this idea because it would work. Your idea of not being able to see threats is not true. Number one the prison has the high ground. They'd be able to see threats coming from far away more than when they are right on top of them. Second, there are GUARD TOWERS that are barely ever used. They can be used to see threats from farrrrr away. The council needs to look at this case again.

 

I really dont understand how you don't understand my points. Number one i didn't say they needed to be in 2-3 towers. 1 tower being used is better than none being used. Second, if im not mistake the prison group had close to 60 people after woodburry. You're saying they dont have enough to be stationed in the towers? Third, the curtains would make other groups aprehensive of coming in past the curtains because they wouldn't fully know whats on the other side. Also the towers would help to see other groups outside of the fences for a change. Maybe if there was someone in the tower a tank wouldn't be able to sneak up on them. I grant that the prison group was weak from the sickness but i would think 1 person would be able to keep watch. Fourth, when the camera is filming the front gate of the fences and is near the prison you can clearly see far away past the fences. (I know that sentecne wasn't worded too well.)That shows that the prison does have some advantage to having the high ground and again, some is better than none. How does any of this not make sense as to why having curtains and someone in a tower is a good idea?

 

Yes and im sureeee you have good reason to disagree. Im guessing those reasons are based off of pride and not wanting to admit that i've given a stronger argument but sure, you can sleep. I didn't post this to argue i mainly just wanted feedback, which was given. Im just surprised no one agreed.

 

And you sure put alot of effort into a side story rather than the real argument which is making me think that you do in fact agree with my points because you have no real rebudle. Every point you have has been countered by my original points. No need to keep this joke, or whatever you're doing, going on any longer. I want to stick to the original discussion not go off on some senseless tangent.