The thing about Carl is that he is not a true asset to the group. You don't rely on him, he's forced to rely on you.

 

She already does. She didn't hold it against Rick for shooting zombie Sophia. It didn't make it any less heartbreaking for her to watch but she knew it was necessary.

I don't know why everyone's already so convinced either Carole or Carl will off her. At this point we don't even know where her story is going.

 

I agree. I'm not sure what everyone was expecting Carl to do there. Take the kid prisoner? It would seem like too much of a hassle with a one-legged old man and a Beth. Also, his kill wasn't premeditated like Carol's or Lizzie's rabbit slaughterings.

 

I just think it would be damaging to Carl to have to kill a little girl, even a crazy mofo like Lizzie. Carol or Rick should do it.

 

I hope Carl doesn't kill Lizzie. It would be bad on a LOT of levels. For example, what kind of scene would TWD have to set up to where Carl sees Lizzie doing something worthy of killing her and yet no one else is around to stop it? Her being left in charge of Judith alone, and she starts strangling her and Carl runs back to get his hat, sees this and shoots her? Please no.

What would happen to Carl in the group after he kills the girl? Rick banished Carol, would he banish Carl? Of course not. Would the rest of the group give him a pass on this disrespecting Carol to her face like that? I hope not.

Would Carl killing Lizzie mean we'd be subjected to another whole hour of Carl trying to show his emotions? GOD, no! PLEASE, no!

 

Carl may have been more important in the comic, but he isn't necessarily the focus in the t.v. show... or has it been stated he is by someone in the know for a fact?

 

Well, I suppose that's the way it's supposed to be, the son supplanting the father. In this case I don't like it.

 

I don't like it either. Neither one of them deserves to be a leader. Maybe part of a council but not the sole authority. Carl is a kid and Rick isn't mentally stable enough.

 

Lizzie is going crazy. Carl isn't as brave or smart, but I think he will become more than what he is (I personally think Rick will eventually die and Carl will become the new badass leader) Lizzie is twisted and she will eventually push it too far, and probably right in front of Carl. I imagine this will take up half a season because Carl will kill her and have to find a way to come back from it. I don't think Carl will ever find out about the suffocating incident though. Lizzie is just like Shane, a natural born leader that sadly goes too far. Except for the fact that she isn't an actor

 

I hope so thts a story ive been waiting to happen and it dhould
by seasons end

 

Did you go to school for this? Nice job. I'm impressed

 

I sure hope so.

 

I don't know whether that school is the neatest thing ever, or the worst possible use of taxpayers money.

 

i think you're forgetting that she nearly killed a baby (and it was obvious that she was mentally unhinged at that moment and not just trying to keep her quiet) and killed a bunch of small rabbits for no apparent reason.

and it most likely wasn't to eat them, or she would have said "hey tyreese, lets eat these rabbits" or something, or at least taken them.

killing small animals without any reason is one of the earliest signs of a serial killer.

 

They totally redid the comics, so I don't think it will be Carl. Carol is alive now, and given her new found pragmatism, it would be poetic irony if she did it. She would have an Of Mice and Men moment that would make the sequence a little less controversial. My #2 choice would be Rick, just to make him a hypocrite and admit that Carol was right when it comes to necessary evils. I guess Tyreese would be my third choice.

The fourth option, and it is a possibility, is that they just banish or abandon her.