Hell no. If you saw my thread a couple of weeks ago, you know I'd rather they see them exile his ass. He's not done double crossing them. Maggie is making a mistake.

 

I was expecting Gregory to not be let in.

 

Realistically no, he’s nothing but a risk for everyone...but I’m glad he’s sticking around to be bossed around by Maggie for a while

 

No, Maggie shouldn't have let Gregory back into the Hilltop. But I expected her to tell Enid that she let Gregory back in because "Its what Glenn would have done."

 

Absolutely not. Her reasoning for keeping him alive was ridiculous. “He’s not worth killing.” Seriously? He’s not worth keeping alive either! He’s a liability and Maggie knows this.

 

It would've been interesting if the people at Hilltop begged Maggie to let Gregory in, and she relented. One thing I loved about the comic book version of "All Out War" was how scared and inexperienced Rick's alliance was. On the show, everyone suddenly became Green Berets.

 

It must be the spirit of ruthless Daryl in me tonight: I wouldn't just turn Gregory away. I would casually kill him to stop his annoying whining lying begging.

 

Nope, but I like to see Maggie being mean to him.

 

This Gregory stuff is gold. He plays a whiny sniveling coward SO WELL. Lol

 

I love all his mini facial expressions as he's grasping for straws, trying to BS his way back into the hilltop.

 

They don't exactly know what we know. Maggie has no idea that Gregory left Gabriel for death. When that comes to light, he will get what's coming.

 

I agree. So far, they don't know all of what he has done. To them, he is a coward without backbone, but not necessarily dangerous. That probably will change, if the truth about Gabriel comes out

 

Honestly, this is how the scene should have been handled and it would have been a wonderful homage to Glenn in general. Her actual reasoning was too cryptic to me, but I agree with her letting Gregory in because they can keep an eye on him - in fact it's best to keep him close considering what ridiculousness/irritation he might create wondering around.

 

Also, what did Gregory mean by "Negan already knew everything?"

What was Gregory trying to imply? Perhaps someone is playing double agent for Negan (and I really don't think it's Gabriel).

 

The garbage people :-/

 

Ahhh.. true! I hadn't considered that.

 

Yeah I think around the time Gregory was leaving for his secret meeting with the saviors, Negan was leaving to show up at Alexandria with Sasha & Eugene...and at that point Jadis and her people had already joined Negan's side. So he at least knew they were getting the communities together to fight and trying to find weapons.