Well, if it is supposed to be a plot twist, do you think the actors would give it away during interviews? I think they aren't allowed to talk about it - they can only talk about "what we know or suspect" on the show, and right now, we are supposed to think it was Carol - I just don't think this is going to be as black and white as it seems. I'm guessing someone else in the prison will turn up mysteriously murdered in the next episode...

look back at episode 2 or 3 when Rick and Tyrese had their brawl over all this. Carol was there, and her reaction upon hearing about the murders was not what you would expect from someone who did it. Something just isn't adding up - that's all I'm saying.

 

Welllllllcommmmme! And yea! Daryl has to totally find her! It would be soooo cute and adorable!

 

I agree, she certainly didn't look or act as sick as the adults. That certainly could be not being able to project the illness as a young actor. You think they could've done something with makeup, to make it evident. After looking at Glenn, I was ready to start digging his grave! While Lizzie didn't seem as sick as the others, I didn't see any evidence between her & Carol's convo that heavily hinted at a cover up. Lizzie' words just made her seem overly naive, confused and delusional. I didn't think there was any that eluded to something transpiring between the two of them.

 

I think she wanted to be sick, and definitely was not. I hope that little creeps story starts unfolding pretty soon...

 

I agree she didn't look sick and when she coughed I just thought she was faking it

 

I don't think she did it...but what are they building up with Lizzie....she is the rat feeder? Will Lizzie's odd behavior not play a part til after they leave the prison?

 

Yeah, I noticed that too. Lizzie even said "I'm not afraid to kill...." Well, if she killed Karen and David, Carol would already know that. I can't imagine if Carol thought Lizzie killed Karen and David, she would send in the girl to quarantine with a knife without talking to her about it. That's not logical. So this makes me think Lizzie didn't do it. Carol could still be covering up for the Dr. though. It's possible she came upon the Dr. doing it and then decided to help him, since she would obviously agree with him. I don't think Carol did it alone, and it just sounds like a Dr. thing, advocating the burning of the bodies.

Rick never asked her if she did it alone- all her answers could still be truthful even if she was with someone else.

 

Imagine if if it's not the super flu and just a regular cold and she got quarantined with the really sick people.

 

She didn't seem sick at all. Glenn and Sasha are sick as dogs, but this little girl isn't even showing many symptoms. Weird.

 

I'm not getting the conspiracy theories either. Lizzie seems to me like she is simply a little girl who has been somewhat sheltered up until this point, and is trying to make sense of her experiences from a child's perspective. Her "humanizing" the walkers really isn't any different than what Herschel's group was doing when rick's group first encountered them. They had the family in the barn, were referring to them by name, thought they were just sick and were feeding them. It also seems to me that much of Carol's behavior is driven by the loss of her daughter, which is why she is trying to teach the children the skills they need to survive. Like Herschel's group, Lizzie is most likely going to learn via harsh reality that these walkers are not "sick", or just a different version of who you once were, and hopefully when that moment comes, Carol's training will not be in vain.

 

Yeah, she doesn't seem like a lunatic either. She's scared is all. And Carol was obviously not lying, she was being really truthful. I'm pretty sure that if it hadn't been Carol but someone "irrelevant" people wouldn't be trying to find excuses so much. Sad, really.

 

This dialogue was very interesting, I also think that either she isn't sick or the actress is terrible. But something is dodgy there...

 

From the time Lizzie did the fake little cough I thought something was up. The fact that she didn't even seem at all sick seems suspicious. I don't think she killed Karen and David - at least not by herself, if she did, someone had to drag two adults outside and she's pretty small - I do think she is the one feeding the walkers rats. Also I found it odd that on one hand Carol told her not to call her "mom" ( even if it was a slip of the tongue), then while talking with Sam and Ana she calls Lizzie and Mika "her girls." ( probably for a different thread, but oh well)

 

It all makes sense now..

 

I'm glad I'm not the only who thought about this.Remember when in the previous episode she told Carol that she is sick and then coughed?->It seemed to me more like fake-coughing.

 

I really feel like she isn't sick, she's sick in the head but not ill. She's pretending to be sick so she can get sick and die, come back as a zombie. "growing up" as she put it?