Thank you for posting that! I agree completely.

 

I may catch flak for this but I've kept my opinion to myself long enough.

I totally hope Judith is dead. If the show caves to people that think it would be to sad to have a baby die then it would be just one more way they are watering down the story. In the comics it was a huge blow when we actually saw Judith

. I understand that they couldn't actually show judith die on the show. That kind of watering down just comes with tv territory and is expected. But to have Judith just show up later fine and dandy? For me that'd suck.

 

I think i have a solution on where she is...

What if Judith is in the backpack that one of the girls has..I think wouldnt that be obvius.But the blood on the carseat that i don't know how to reply....

 

She might be stuffed in the toes of Lizzie's shoe.

 

Part of me really wants her to live, but this is a show about brutal realism, and having her die is probably the correct artistic choice, I agree. If she doesn't die at some point, we're going to have to watch her grow up, and in season 8 she'll be like a 5 year old, that somehow keeps surviving through all types of catastrophes, and it could get cheesy.

 

Judith is the ticket that lets Carol live and rejoin the group. She's alive.

Besides, there're lots of things that were one way in the comic and totally different on the show. Lori was dead a long time when the Governor attacked the prison for the last time.

 

S4E10 Spoiler:

 

Did I miss that scene? Don't remember seeing Tyrese clutching something to his chest. Run out from under the bridge. I must have miss that scene. Cause it happen so fast.