I could write a novel on why Shane is better than Rick, but I'll keep it simple.

Rick is a naive wussy.

Shane would have killed off the prisoners first thing (which Rick should have), this would have eliminated the major "zombie outbreak" that cost people their lives.

If Rick wasn't such a wuss, his wife would still be alive.

When Shane said "I don't think you can keep them safe", he wasn't being a dick. He was being honest.

And he was right.

PS: I also thought Rick was being a complete wussy/dumbass when he was talking to people on the Phone. Now it's evident that he's a complete psycho, but before that I thought he was VERY weak for assuming some random caller on the phone wasn't suspicious, and that they would actually have a "safe place".

Rick is a failure.

(u mad?)

Shane should be the man.

 

I'm calling your BS and I'll raise you a fact: Shane kept them safe for months before big daddy Rick showed up.

Rick gets them for .5 a season and blows it.

The statistics speak for themselves.

I personally know who my money would be on to lead my group.



(And I wouldn't have suffered the stupid idea of keeping the prisoners alive who are blatantly shady).

Sure, 2 of them are good, but that 1 bad apple cost his wife. Is that a good deal to you? (He also lost some key party members with his poor naive decision making).

 

Not really a troll, I think Rick has poor decision skills.

Are you saying that keeping the prisoners was a good idea? (lol).

Or that Rick talking to imaginary people on the phone and then begging them for help is a good idea?

:/

 

The reason Shane went insane is cause he knew Rick was incapable of making decisions that would keep his family safe.

And, he was proven correct.

Lol. I know Shane is dead.

I'm just saying, he was a better leader. That is all. You can agree or disagree, I've made my case; you can make yours.

 

I think Lori is more at fault for that, she should have just dropped all the drama, but instead she kept on saying "Omg I'm so sorry Shane" rofl. Way to bring up emotions in a stressful situation.

Remember when Shane was fixing the windmill (or whatever the hell he was doing lol) and Lori came and interrupted him? Lori would always do that; bring up feelings that were better left buried. Of course Shane went crazy.

No matter how you cut the mustard, Shane was about one thing; protecting his lady and his kid.

Meanwhile, Rick is out there playing good Samaritan.

Who would you want as your leader?

Someone who cares only about keeping you alive, or someone who is out there playing good citizen hereby endangering the group? The facts speak for themselves.