Carol's were actually nicely done and with pretty sombre atmosphere. Rick's were garbage.

 

I loved Carol's crashing! OMG, Daryl fixing breakfast! Then it was heartbreaking to realize Carol was tormented by sleep because she would be reunited with her son and then have to wake up to his loss all over again.

Whenever Carol was coming down the stairs, I thought she might still be dreaming. I was confused whether she was seeing real walkers or hallucinating them. I like that I was the one who was so uncertain of what was real. They did such a good job with Carol's two worlds.

But I also loved Rick's phone calls and his utter desolation. I can't pick a favorite. They're both tens for me.

 

RICK for the win

Rick's hallucinations are organic in nature

Carol has to depend on pills to induce hallucinations








Of course I am woman enough to admit that I struggle with liking Carol - I just cannot seem to forgive stupid comic book Carol LMAO!!!

 

I have to vote for Rick too. His was more on the PTSD side and hers has a lot to do with being medicated.

 

Hard to choose. Both had to do with trying to grapple with losing people they loved. Rick’s cray came easily in the early days of the ZA when he wasn’t as hardened. Carol had gone through losing a lot of loved ones by this time. She had steeled herself to the reality of the times she was living in and may have repressed the cray if it wasn’t for her being on those pills which allowed things to come to the forefront.

 

Really?



That was pretty weak to me.

 

Ugh, I didn't read this before posting my question about the final scene. I thought the shot Walker came from Carol's encounter with them in the woods, didn't remember the gym.

 

Question - when Daryl found Carol in the gym, was she surrounded by walker bodies?

 

Thank you. When they returned to Alexandria, they simply told Siddiq that she fell on glass. I wasn't sure that the walker bodies were real!

 

We gotta subdivide Rick's... he had quite a few! The phone calls were brilliant, I thought, such a surreal feel to that episode. Lori in the white dress everywhere was lame, and his final hallucinations before he nearly died of blood loss, were pretty awesome. (I just wished he had a chance to see Glenn and Carl as well, but hey.) Worst hallucinations ever on the show, were Tyreese's, imo. And Carol's were the best blurred-line ones. They kept you guessing and double guessing for sure!

 

I think I am the only person who liked What Happened and What's Going On.

 

Oh I wasn't thinking about those! Yeah that was great.