I have a feeling that people in the ASZ don't have 'incident reports' to fill out. "They ran off into the woods after we defeated them" is likely where the 'report' ended. I think it's pretty reasonably to ask her what direction they headed. She was the only one of the three who was there.

 

It wouldn't have even mattered, because Dwight's group could of been ANYWHERE by that point.

 

I still don't really see the problem here. Even if Rosita had previously told them "they went east" or whatever, I think it would still be natural to ask about the direction from the only person who was actually there when it happened. "East" can encompass a pretty broad range of potential directions in any practical sense of the word.

 

So if someone told you "they ran off to the east of the tracks" would you just assume that you should head due east from the tracks? This is a silly complaint. Rosita was there. Glenn and Michonne were not there. It makes complete sense to follow the person who actually saw them leave, regardless of any information you may have had previously.

 

i agree. If the Saviors were skilled enough to trap 4 of our guys, wouldn't they be smart enough to disguise their getaway route?

 

Why are the Saviors still lurking around in that same patch of woods? Is that where they live?

 

What do you expect Rosita to do? Give them a detailed map?! She had to tend to Eugene's injuries before she could even begin to track those Saviors. At most, all she could of told them that more Saviors were out there.

And that area is most likely their ambush point, and Rosita and the rest of Rick's Group probably assumed that the Saviors were not ever going to use that area for an ambush.

 

Is that even supposed to be the same area? I can't tell because it's a f*cking forest for Christ's sake.

 

I think it has everything to do with it. They may be rough but they're not stupid. They're not dumb enough to flee into the direction of their hole up. Rosita could've lead them, but who knows if they're still in the area?

Rosita *wanted* to be on this mission, thus she kept the info until she was on the way

 

Are you saying that Rosita told NONE of Rick's Group about the incident? With Denise DEAD and Eugene INJURED, she's basically forced to tell them what went down. You act like she, Daryl, Eugene, and Abraham just kept their lips zipped tight.

At most all Rosita could have said was that their were more Saviors out there. She has no idea where they went, nor where they are hold up. Unless she has access to the Season 7 script, i'd say your asking too much from her.

 

I think they'd run right for their hole-up. They just lost more than half their group, and if there are more of them at their base, they could have gotten them to fight back Daryl's group. If they were worried about being pursued, and they should have been, going back for help would be the way a panicked bunch would think.

 

I really think this is just a silly complaint. You're making it sound like Rosita had some kind of ulterior motive here in deliberately not telling them what direction to go.

This is incredibly simple. She. Was. There. She saw them leave. She visually watched them walk away. No amount of verbal or written description is going to give either Glenn or Michonne a better idea of where to go than what Rosita would have. It is absolutely natural to follow the person who SAW IT HAPPEN. As I said previously, she could have said "they went northeast" and it would still make far more sense to ask her "what direction did they go" when reaching the point from which they headed northeast. She might remember that "they went past this group of trees". How is she going to describe that group of trees? "It's the group of short trees with the tall tree in the middle" or something like that? Would Glenn and Michonne remember her description and think "oh, there's a group of short trees with a tall tree, that surely must be the exact group of trees out of this entire forest that Rosita was referring to. Let's not ask Rosita what direction to go in and just assume that we have 100% understanding of her report. We'll lead the way instead of letting the person who SAW IT HAPPEN lead the way."

Yeah, this complaint is useless.