http://ricksdicktatorship.tumblr.com/post/49035995492

Obviously she should have instinctively known that it was Daryl, despite the fact that he looked and moved like one of the millions of monsters now roaming the Earth! Gawd.

Silly little girl, not listening to the men like she was supposed to. By the way, what was Daryl doing out there again? Oh, yeah, he stole a horse, ran off and lost said horse while nearly getting himself killed for not listening...nevermind though, he has a ***** so it's ok.

EDIT:- I love how the latest 4 posters in this thread are all "Andrea's Angels".

 

Personally I like the shows characters better for the most part. A couple I gave to the comics could also change as the show progresses.

Rick - incomplete
Carl - comic
Shane - show
Lori - show
Morgan - show
Andrea - comic
Glenn - show
Maggie - show
Hershel - show
Tyreese - comic
Dale - show
Sophia - show
Otis - show
The Governor - show
Jim - show
Amy - show
Michonne - comic

 

Rick - Show
Carl - Comic
Lori - I hate both of them but show Lori is better
Shane - Show
Dale - Show
Andrea - Show and Comic, don't make me choose!
Amy - Show
Glenn - No preference
Jim - No preference
Carol - Show by a landslide
Sophia - Comic
Hershel - Show
Maggie - Def show
Patricia - Show
Otis - Show
Michonne - Comic so far
Axel - Comic
Tyreese - I guess comic because we haven't seen much of show Tyreese
The Governor - Show
Caesar - Show

 

Rick: Show
Lori: Show
Shane: Show
Carl: Comics
Glenn: Comics
Governor: Comics
Andrea: Comics
Dale: Show
Hershel: Show
Jim: Show
Maggie: Show
Axel: Comics
Martinez: Comic
Carol: Show
Sophia: Comics
Michonne: Comics

 

What are the conditions? Because I think it's a little unfair to compare the Show characters to their Comic-Counterparts that were/are around longer, have more development.

For example, I think TV Rick and Carl are better then Comic Rick and Carl during the Prison Arc. However, current Comic Rick and Carl are better.

 

I agree. Sometimes people forget that the comic book characters have had more time. People automatically say comic book Rick is better when TV Rick hasn't even left the prison. Up to this point, I like where TV Rick has gone better. Carl didn't really start to develop until after they left the prison as well, so I feel the same way about Carl. Honestly, I believe the show has superior characters. People already give the edge to a few/many of the shows characters, and there have only been three seasons so far. The acting does help too, The Walking Dead has cast everyone extremely well.

 

Show Hershel is so much better than comic Hershel, I agree.

 

Rick - Comics
Shane - show
Hershel - show
Glenn - show
Carl - comic
Andrea - comic
Michone - comic
Lori - didnt really like her at all lol
Tyreese - Comic
Carol - show
Maggie - show
Dale - comic
Gov - comic

 

I have a question, how would you compare show Rick up to the point when comic Rick was at the prison? I think it's a little unfair to pick on certain characters because they've been through more in the comic.

 

Well in tht case u really cant compare them but id have to go
bck and read a few issues again been thinking about rereading them all anyway

 

Rick- Show
Carl- Undecided
Shane- Show
Lori- Comic
Morgan- Show
Andrea- Comic
Glenn- Show
Maggie- Show
Hershel- Show
Tyreese- Comic
Dale- Show
Carol- Show
Sophia- Comic
Otis- Show
The Governor- Show
Martinez- Show
Jim- Show
Amy- Equal
Michonne- Show
Axel- Comic

 

Rick - Comics
Carl - Comics
Lori - Comics
Shane - TV
Morgan - TV
Duane - TV
Glenn - Comics
Dale - TV
Jim - TV
Carol - TV
Sophia - Comics
Andrea - Comics
Amy - TV
Maggie - Comics/TV
Hershel - TV
Patricia - Comics
Otis - TV
Axel - Comics
Andrew - Comics
Caesar - Comics
The Governor - Comics/TV
Tyreese - Comics
Allen - Comics
Michonne - Comics/TV
Bob - TV
Lilly - Comics/TV

 

Rick - Comics
Carl - TV Show
Lori - Comics
Shane - TV Show
Morgan - TV Show
Duane - TV Show
Glenn - TV Show
Dale - Comics
Jim - TV Show
Carol - TV Show
Sophia - Comics
Andrea - Comics
Amy - TV Show
Maggie - TV Show
Hershel - TV Show
Patricia - Comics
Otis - Comics
Axel - TV Show
Andrew - Comics
Caesar - Comics
The Governor - TV Show
Tyreese - TV Show
Allen - Comics
Michonne - Comics
Bob - TV Show

The Governor was so much better in the TV Show, at least in terms of how the character was written and developed, in the TV Show we had a reason as to why he is who he is, and overall Woodbury is so much better in the show as well; they did a really good job with that story arc.

 

I do agree about TG in some ways. In the comics I really felt slapped in the face just like that. He takes them in and in a second turns into some crazy maniac. At least in the TV shows I didn't "suspect" it (if you know what I mean)

 

IMO, the differences are the following:

Better on TV
1- Carol In my opinion, she is the biggest change from comics to TV. The comic Carol is the weakest of the group, including the children. She lives for the acceptance of others, and is tormented when others don't love her enough. Then you have TV Carol, who is arguably one of the strongest of the group. She is one of my favorites on the TV show. Strong, decisive, and always willing to step up. But obviously like every good character, she isn't perfect.

2- Hershel Wins second place for best improvement from the comics. Seeing TV Hershel slowing change overtime, but still retain his pure nature is quite interesting and inspiring. In the comics, he just seemed a bit off to me. The biggest example is the walker filled barn. With the TV Hershel, I could kind of understand where he was coming from. But in the comics he just seems like some crazy guy who doesn't know how to control them at all.

Better in the Comics
3- Maggie/Glenn I have only read through Comic 60, but so far I think they are better in the comics. In the TV show, I really liked Glenn... Until he started revolving around Maggie. In the comics they deal with real issues and develop. In the TV show... They just waste screen time. Obviously, this is just my opinion. But I hope one of them dies soon so the other can move on and grow. Actually, as long as they stay separated for a while I will be happy.

4- Rick/Carl - I know Rick is a flawed character and that is the point, but I have yet to strongly disagree with anything that comic Rick as done (through issue 60). Rick on the TV show makes me cringe. I liked him season 1 and 2, but now every time I see him I don't root for him like I used to. Carl also seems more vulnerable and like able in the comics. In the TV show they try to hard to make him look like a BA. I'd rather see him as a real child.

Obviously all of the characters are a bit different, but in my opinion, these are the only ones that I feel the most strongly about.

 

Rick: Comcis
Carl: Comics
Michonne: Comics
Lori: TV
Shane: TV
Andrea: Comics
Dale: Comics
Sophia: Comics
Glenn: TV
Maggie: Comics
Hershel: Show
Governor: Show
Carol: Show
Tyreese: Show

 

Rick: tv
Carl: Comics
Michonne: Comics
Lori: tv
Shane: tv
Andrea: Comics
Dale: comic
Sophia: tv* if she didn't die I think Carol wouldn't be as awesome as she is now
Glenn: comic
Maggie: Tv
Hershel: tv
Governor: tv
Carol: tv
Tyreese: comic*so far the tv Tyresse has been kinda a disappointment, his fight with Rick wasn't as great as I thought it would be.hope the next half with him will change my mind
Axel Comic
Amy:tv
Morgan tv
Otis:tv
Patricia:comic
Allen:comic
ben:comic

 

Rick - Show
Carl - Comics
Lori - Comics
Shane - Show
Morgan - Show
Glenn - Show
Dale - Comics
Andrea - Comics
Carol - Show
Hershel - Show (myfavorite!!)
Maggie - Show
Patricia - Comics
Otis - Show
Michonne - Comics
Axel - Show (This might be the biggest difference for me, next to Andrea. I loved TVAxel. I couldn't stomach GN Axel. "You follow me?" UGH!!)
Governor - Show
Martinez - Show
Tyreese - This one might be dead even for me. But Chad Coleman doesn't play aggressive badass as well as he plays the sensitive teddy bear, IMO.