No.

 

Clear was very sad and dark, much more than this past episode. Seeing the pain in Morgan and how he explained how he kept radioing Rick but he never answered. Then the brutality of the ZA was brought home with the backpack scene at the end.

 

There have been sadder episodes, but yes, seeing Carol being left behind was very sad to watch.

 

Clear is one of my favorite episodes, but I think this episode is more sad. It even has a sad song at the end.

 

I was sad by the end of the episode, yes.

 

It was very sad, partly b/c it was so unexpected (to me) that Rick cut Carol loose.
My other sad ones would be Clear, Killer Within, This Sorrowful Life, Better Angels...Infected is up there too.

 

Killer whittin is still the saddest episode so far. This one wasn't that sad. Maybe becauss I dislike Carol.

 

I didn't think it was sad at all, she'll be back anyway.

 

Pretty much dead already is the saddest imo ... but this one was pretty sad too! Especially the part where Carol speaks of the abuse she suffered ...

 

Nah, I wasn't sad. The saddest and best ep for me was "Pretty Much Dead Already" Not only for the obvious Sophia thing but because the whole situation was messed up!

*shane getting Hershels barn walkers/relatives killed so Rick had to make a point and kill Sophia
* the fact they were probs going to get kicked off the farm because of what Shane did even though Lori was preggers
*Hershel having to come to terms with his relatives being undead and not just "sick"
*Maggie in tears giving the okay for Glenn to shoot at her step mom etc.
*Glenn having to step up but asking Maggie first was sad/cute
*Poor old Dale making it there late cos he was so old and stuff and being threatened by Shane
*Lori telling Shane even if the baby is his, it's not - and having him go more insane etc.

That ep had everything. This one just had Rick clumsily and rushedly turfing Carol out for the SAME REASON she killed in the first place, to protect the group.

GRRRR! Angst!

 

It was sad, but after what she did, I really don't care for Carol anymore. I really didn't like her character that much before, but now I certainly don't. It really wasn't that hard to see her go, at least for me anyway. And I'm sure the show will continue to follow Carol.

The saddest part was Rick talking about normal life with Lori and Carl.

 

One of the saddest I guess, but This Sorrowful Life wins. Probably because Merle was already one of my two favorite characters before he passed.

 

I felt sad when Andrea went, that was a hard thing for Michonne to have to do.
I know many didn't like Andrea, and at times she was pig headed but she tried to unite Ricks group and the governors group. She was naive but an optimist.

 

I thought it was one of the awesomest, I loved it, I want MOAR!

 

The end was kinda sad... watching Carol in tears. We heard the song again that was used in trailer (only a different version) in the end of episode which was great. And you could see in Rick's eyes that he wasn't happy at all when he made that decision.

 

In my opinion it was up there with 1x04, 3x04, 3x15 and 3x16.
Watching Carol tear up as she realises she's losing everything she's worked to protect was just heartbreaking as a Viewer. we've known These characters for three to four years now and watching something like this is never easy.
The woman now has nothing, No daughter, no husband and no friends she's lost everything yet again

 

Episode 2 Infected was a hell of a lot more sadder than this one.

 

Not really, I never liked the character much anyway even when I could tolerate her. The deaths of Dale, Lori, Merle and Andrea were much sadder.