Yeah you're right. And she's a former lawyer, and plays the devil advocate on occasions. The scenarists made a pitiful job with her character in season 3.

 

There isn't one good point to Andrea in the show. They brutalized her. She is one of the best characters in the comic. In the show, she wasn't even close to being even a shell of her comic book counterpart. So sad.

 

Well I haven't read the comics, I don't know how different she is from the tv show but I've always liked her because she reacts in a very human way, like Carol. She's no stereotype. But all the characters in season 3 were mistreated, the only good point being that we get to see a bit of Merle again, at last...