The episode got a 10 in my book as soon as I seen Morgan kicking some ass in that first scene! IMO That was a fantastic finale!!!

 

10, nearly flawless.

Whoever voted that 1, remove yourself from our lives.

 

Why is "****ing 1000" not an option on the poll?

 

Fantastic episode. The sense that no one was safe was heavy as a fog. I give it a 10.

 

I never vote on these because I like to wait until a season is over and think about how the episodes fit together for a while before I can compare them, but there's no question this episode is a 10.

 

5?!?! 1????????????!!!!! Who do we live with?!

 

A 10 for me... I just Loved it.
btw... Who gave an 1? c'mon.

 

We need to start making votes public so I know who to block on this forum.

 

10 should be the only option on dis poll. Or like @HondaS2kXD said 1000.

 

It's a 10. One of the best episodes of the show. Heart pounding, heart warming, just everything.

 

I never give these out with very few exceptions, but a 10.

 

10 for sure. Best episode of the season by far.

 

I've never given a 10 until tonight!

 

TWD is by far my favorite show on tv, and this season was overall a strong season, but this episode could possibly be my least favorite of the series. I have many reasons for this:

The Wolves are still not completely integrated into the show as they have been hinted at for 7 episodes.
Daryl, Aaron and Morgan all escaping a no-win situation unharmed.
Absolutley no one keeping guard at ASZ gate or watchtower.
Nicholas stating that he is scared of outside, yet climbs the fence to do go outside during the night.
Glenn not killing a person that shot him and killed Noah.
Father Gabriel's incomprehensible behavior, Sasha lying in the grave, and Maggie praying with them after a confusing struggle.
Nobody seemed worried about the missing people during the campfire scene - which included the main subjects of the meeting - as this would in reality would cause concern.
Nobody was guarding Pete's home after he was definitely a threat to Jessie, Sam and Rick.
Morgan, Aaron and Daryl simply showing up at the end without having a potentially emotional Rick-Morgan reunion.

There was a pro to this episode however: the opening scene was very high-quality and entertaining.
Also, Deanna now seems to understand Rick's philosphy.
Hopefully, Season 6 will learn from the character and situational mistakes of this season and introduce and very potent threat in the Wolves.

 

Did you gave it an 1?

 

i gave it a 5. It was not a bad episode, but had a lot of issues

 

Sounds like YOU'RE the one with issues. This was a solid 10, dude!

 

I agree. There was something with this episode that I just didn't do it for me. Some parts were great, but overall...I don't know how I feel about it. But I gave it a 6 cause of Michonne and Sasha. :zombies_lol:

 

My first 10..., no question